If your monthly report shows engagement down 18 percent, there are two possible explanations. The work got worse, or last month contained one post that did not repeat.
Distinguishing between those two is the whole job of a social media report, and most reports are built in a way that cannot do it. Here is the measurement that shows why.
Over the 90 days to 5 September 2026 I collected every post published by 60 public brand and publisher accounts on Bluesky, from the public API. For the 31 accounts that published at least 100 original posts, I added up likes, reposts, replies and quotes on every post and looked at how that total is distributed inside each account.
Across those 31 accounts, the median account gets 37.9 percent of its engagement from its best 10 percent of posts, and half of its engagement from its best 17.5 percent.
Average engagement per post is the total interactions in a period divided by the number of posts published in that period. In this study, interactions are likes, reposts, replies and quotes on an account’s own original posts; replies by the account are excluded and impressions are not counted. The median is the middle post’s count instead.
The concentration varies enormously, and the busiest accounts are the worst
| Account | Posts | Share of engagement from the top 10% of posts | Share of posts producing half of all engagement |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Verge | 1,753 | 78% | 0.9% |
| Rolling Stone | 635 | 64% | 3.0% |
| NBA | 585 | 57% | 6.3% |
| Netlify | 180 | 54% | 8.3% |
| Axios | 383 | 54% | 7.8% |
| Wired | 1,033 | 51% | 9.7% |
| TechCrunch | 1,452 | 48% | 11.6% |
| The Wall Street Journal | 2,465 | 48% | 11.5% |
| 404 Media | 449 | 46% | 12.5% |
| The New York Times | 2,279 | 46% | 12.5% |
| Reuters | 2,454 | 46% | 12.3% |
| Internet Archive | 123 | 42% | 15.4% |
| The New Yorker | 2,071 | 39% | 16.0% |
| Semafor | 1,420 | 39% | 17.2% |
| The Associated Press | 2,480 | 38% | 17.6% |
| The Atlantic | 2,375 | 38% | 17.3% |
| The Guardian | 2,495 | 37% | 17.5% |
| Bloomberg | 2,403 | 37% | 18.3% |
| Ars Technica | 1,221 | 37% | 19.7% |
| The Economist | 2,492 | 35% | 19.5% |
| Polygon | 2,500 | 32% | 22.3% |
| New Scientist | 2,355 | 32% | 22.1% |
| Vox | 505 | 31% | 23.0% |
| NPR | 2,204 | 31% | 23.5% |
| Nature | 786 | 31% | 22.3% |
| EFF | 540 | 28% | 24.6% |
| PlayStation | 121 | 28% | 26.4% |
| Engadget | 1,633 | 26% | 26.6% |
| IGN | 309 | 25% | 29.1% |
| Wikipedia | 150 | 24% | 32.0% |
| Crunchyroll | 204 | 19% | 34.3% |
The Verge is the extreme case, and it is worth stating precisely. It published 1,753 posts in the window. Its best 1 percent of posts, about seventeen of them, carry 51.8 percent of everything the account earned. Its best 10 percent carry 78 percent. Half of its 90 day engagement comes from 0.9 percent of its posts.
At the other end, Crunchyroll’s best 10 percent carry 19 percent of its total and it takes a third of its posts to reach half. That is close to what an evenly performing account looks like, and only one account in this set is anywhere near it.
Six of the 31 accounts get half or more of their engagement from a tenth of their posts.

What this does to a monthly number
Remove the single best post from each account and recompute its mean engagement per post. Across the 31 accounts, the median account’s mean falls by 2.6 percent. That sounds harmless until you look at the accounts where it does not:
- Rolling Stone: removing one post of 635 drops the account’s mean engagement per post by 30.4 percent.
- Axios: one post of 383, 23.1 percent.
- TechCrunch: one post of 1,452, 14.1 percent.
- The Verge: one post of 1,753, 11.9 percent.
One post. Not a bad month, not an algorithm change, not a strategy failure. A single item, removed from a quarter of output, moving the headline number by up to thirty percent.
If your report says engagement per post rose or fell by twenty percent and your account looks anything like Rolling Stone’s, that number contains no information about the work at all. It tells you whether one thing happened.
Average vs median engagement per post
The average, or mean, adds up every post’s interactions and divides by the number of posts, so the interactions on a hit are spread across the whole period. The median is the interaction count of the middle post once every post is sorted, so a hit counts as one post among many and no more.
Rolling Stone shows the difference with the figures already above. It published 635 posts in the window. Its median post earned 45 interactions and its best post earned 27,742, more than 600 times the median. Remove that one post and the mean engagement per post falls by 30.4 percent. The median of the remaining 634 posts can only move to the value of a neighbouring post in the sorted list, so it barely changes. The Verge is the same pattern at a larger scale: a median of 31 against a best post of 29,819, and an 11.9 percent fall in the mean when that single post is removed.
The two numbers answer different questions. The mean says how much engagement the period produced per post; the median says what a typical post earned. On accounts shaped like these, the median is far less sensitive to a single post.
The gap between the best post and the normal post
The reason this happens is visible in a single ratio. On The Verge’s account, the best post earned 29,819 interactions and the median post earned 31. That is a factor of nearly a thousand. Rolling Stone: 27,742 against 45. TechCrunch: 6,229 against 17.
Those accounts are not producing a stream of similar things with some variation. They are producing a large number of small results and a very small number of enormous ones, and any summary statistic that mixes the two will be dominated by whichever enormous ones happened to land in the reporting period.
What to report instead
- Report the median, and report the count of posts above a threshold you set once. “Median interactions per post” plus “posts above 500 interactions” describes both the normal work and the hits, and neither number swings on a single item.
- Show the distribution once a quarter. A simple sorted bar of every post’s engagement makes the shape obvious to a stakeholder in a way no summary can, and it inoculates them against the next month-on-month swing. The quarterly client review meeting is a natural place to show it.
- Name the outlier explicitly in the report. If one post carried the month, say so and link it. That is the most useful sentence on the page and it stops the number being misread as a trend. If you work from a social media reporting template, add a median row and an outlier note to it.
- When you compare periods, compare like for like. Same definition, same denominator, and if one period contains an outlier that the other does not, say which. Definitions matter inside the total too: what Meta’s documentation counts as a save is a reminder that each interaction type is defined separately.
- Do not chase the outlier. Nothing here says the big posts are reproducible. The accounts with the highest concentration are not the ones with the best results per post; The Verge’s median post earns 31 interactions.
What this cannot tell you
- One platform, 90 days, one collection date, 31 accounts weighted towards news and technology publishers. Publishers post far more than most brands, and post volume is part of what produces this shape.
- Engagement here is likes, reposts, replies and quotes on the account’s own posts. Replies by the account are excluded. Impressions are not available on this platform, so none of this is a reach measurement.
- Nine of the highest volume accounts hit the collection page cap of 2,500 posts, so their windows are shorter than 90 days. Concentration is a within-account proportion and is not distorted by that, but the post counts shown are floors.
- Counts move. Everything here is as read on 5 September 2026, and recent posts in the window have had less time to accumulate than older ones, which if anything understates concentration.
FAQ
What is a good average engagement per post?
No universal figure holds. The number depends on the platform, the account’s size, which interactions are counted and whether the summary is a mean or a median, and on accounts like these a single post can move the mean by up to 30 percent. The Verge’s median post here earned 31 interactions and Rolling Stone’s 45; those describe these accounts on Bluesky, not a benchmark. Compare an account against its own history under one definition, as set out in Five ways to say engagement rate.
Source ledger
- Post records: the public Bluesky AppView API (
public.api.bsky.app), endpointsapp.bsky.actor.getProfileandapp.bsky.feed.getAuthorFeed, read without authentication on 5 September 2026. 60 accounts, 45,026 posts; this piece uses the 31 accounts with at least 100 original posts in the window. - The definitional problem that sits underneath this one, five common ways to calculate an engagement rate and the four different winners they produce, is Five ways to say engagement rate.



